Very high potential
FL Studio, I presume? (then again, I usually presume wrong)
Overall Impression:
Very upbeat and what I like to call "floaty." I feel that the mark of the trance song is the gate, and you've obviously mastered it here. I just felt really calm as I listened to this short song. This song flows like a river in the heavens (pardon my cheesy analogy)
Melodies:
I am simply awed by your chord progression. Brilliantly woven and sewn together. Yet I feel this song could be so much more than just a pad song, if you add basically any lead. But that's at your discretion not mine.
Percussion/Bass Line:
Not much to say here. I guess the standard trance percussion progression fits here, not too much you can do to make it better, except add some transitions in the full piece.
Instrument Choice:
Please, please, PLEASE tell me what pad you used (Sounds like Nexus, but then again I might be wrong). I'm also a trance writer and gates have always frustrated me!!!! Yours just fits so well with the chord progression and beat of the song. Everything else seems to be in its place too for the moment. Good work!
Rhythm:
I guess I'll mention the gating rhythm here. Now, I have nothing against using the classic 16th 16th 8th gating rhythm, but you should definitely experiment with more, if not in the full piece, in future songs. That's all for that
Intro/Conclusion:
Not really applicable, since it is a WIP. I'm sure you'll think of something awesome
Transitions:
If you do add more discernible transitions, which I highly recommend, it will make your piece flow that much better. Even simple cymbal (try saying that 5 times fast) crashes will work for a piece like this. Again, since it's a WIP I'm not too focused on that.
Miscellaneous:
I wonder why it's called Berlin?
Good work, keep it up, and update me with the full version and I'll review that too. If you have the time, I humbly request a review on my latest trance song "Celestial Plane."
Review by TheBellmaker, former RRC member
Saw your song on the listed, decided to view it.